Blog

  • My first book is published! Heaviness in Metal Music, with Oxford University Press

    I’m thrilled to share that, after several years of hard work, my first book has been published with Oxford University Press!

    The full text was released today, and can be read online for free through Oxford Academic: https://academic.oup.com/book/62310

    The book is also available for pre-order in paperback, hardback, or E-book editions, which will be released in April 2026.

    A million thanks to my acquisition editor, Norm Hirschy, who guided me through the book proposal process back in 2023, and then offered to include my book in an open-access initiative.

    Long-time readers of my work will recognize parts of Chapters 5, 8, 9, and 10, but they have all been updated and expanded with new material and ideas to match this book’s broader context and arguments about heaviness as a participatory experience, its origins within the blues, and how it shaped the emergence and evolution of metal.


    Here’s a brief preview of what’s in the book:

    Heaviness in Metal Music

    Heaviness in metal music is not just a timbre or quality of sound—it’s an experience of impact that listeners help create. This book combines methodologies from musicology, music theory, cognitive science, and performance studies to define heaviness as a cross-sensory experience and aesthetic practice. Heaviness is shaped by what we do when we listen, how we think about metal music, and how we relate to the people who make and listen to it.

    By studying the origins of heaviness, this book overturns common myths about metal’s history. Heaviness and the musical practices associated with it emerged from 1960s White audiences’ encounters with Black American music styles, especially the blues. Despite metal’s historical narrative of “leaving the blues behind,” many aspects of the genre perpetuate legacies of blues’s musical style and highly racialized reception—including headbanging, and metal’s ideologies and aesthetics of oppositional authenticity, loudness, heaviness, and extremity.

    Musicians and listeners navigate their own way through this landscape of legacies, re-enacting the genre’s ideologies and musical structures through their own headbanging and moshing. When musicians use the most common drum patterns and song forms in metal, they perpetuate the genre’s norms and practices, but they also provide a framework for the creation and distinction of new metal styles and experiences. This book concludes with the argument that longstanding restrictions about who and what count as metal have recently begun to loosen, expanding the scope of what heaviness can mean, and to whom.


    Table of Contents

    PART I. WHAT IS HEAVINESS?

    Introduction

    1. Experiencing Heavy Timbres Through Metaphors: Buzzsaw Tone

    2. Power Chords and the Basic Illusion of Heaviness: Hearing Something More Powerful Than Reality

    3. Rock Is Dead, But Metal Will Live Forever: The Paradoxes of Metal’s Progressionism

    PART II. WHERE DID HEAVINESS COME FROM?

    4. Leaving the Blues Behind: The Racialized Origins of Metal and Its Progression Toward Heaviness

    5. Headbanging as a Legacy of Black Dance

    6. Angels and Demons: Hearing Gender and Heaviness in Metal’s Fantastical Vocals

    PART III. HOW IS HEAVINESS CREATED AND WHAT DOES IT FEEL LIKE?

    7. How Metallica Created Extreme Metal: Active Listening, Connoisseurship, and Cover Songs

    8. Headbanging to Drum Patterns to Create Heaviness

    9. How Song Forms Create Ritual Spaces for Experiencing Heaviness

    10. Feeling Different Heavinesses in Different Song Forms and Subgenres

    Epilogue: The Promise of Post-Extreme Metal

  • University of Iowa Colloquium Talk: Meshuggah, Groove, Complexity

    On February 6, 2026, I was honored to give a talk at the University of Iowa as part of their Musicology/Music Theory Colloquium series, hosted by Prof. Joshua Albrecht. I gave an hour-long lecture about the Swedish extreme metal band Meshuggah, consisting of material from my second book project, which I’m currently drafting.

    My work on Meshuggah is building very directly on my first book, which is now available open-access through Oxford University Press!

    Please feel free to reach out if you’d like to know more about this project! You can always find my contact information at my faculty bio page for my job at Occidental College.

    Here’s a short description of my talk:

    The Swedish extreme metal band Meshuggah has already been the subject of extensive music analysis research. My first intervention is to retheorize Meshuggah’s distinctive complex rhythms as “overlays,” a groove-based construction which repeats a short unit of odd length to create a rival accent pattern over 4/4—which has been previously studied in jazz, soul, and EDM by Pressing (2002), Cohn (2016), and Butler (2006). This retheorization connects existing Meshuggah research with numerous concepts to better explain the physical experiences that their rhythms create (groove and perceptual rivalry, cycles of release and relock, metrical displacement, etc.). My second intervention is to highlight Meshuggah’s connection to previous thrash/groove metal (which also frequently used overlay riffs), helping to explain their music’s brutal physicality in terms of new research on previous metal practices of heaviness, headbanging, etc. This reverses a trend in existing research which mostly highlights Meshuggah’s “deviance” from mainstream metal (Capuzzo 2018). Overlay analysis shows how even Meshuggah’s most complex, “mathematical” riffs emerge from recursive recombination of physical, groove-oriented riff techniques from previous metal. These two interventions connect analysis of Meshuggah’s music directly to ideas about groove and physicality from studies of African diaspora popular music traditions, troubling common assumptions about complexity, detachment, and race in popular music—and especially in the context of thrash metal, a genre which is often described as “leaving the blues behind” through increased complexity, detachment, and control (Pillsbury 2006). I end with broader thoughts about musical complexity: problematizing the association of certain kinds of complexity with whiteness or embodied detachment, questioning the status of complexity in music theory, and riffing on old questions about mind-body dualism.

  • Society for Music Theory: “Corpus of Chaos: Headbanging to Conventional Form Cues in Meshuggah’s Unconventional Songs”

    On November 7, 2025, I gave a talk at the national American Musicological Society–Society for Music Theory joint annual meeting in Minneapolis. I’ve presented there a few times before, but this time I was there to talk about my second book project, about the Swedish extreme metal band Meshuggah.

    If you’re interested, I’d be happy to share my slides and script! Feel free to email me to ask. You can always find my contact information at my faculty bio page for my job at Occidental College.

    Here’s the official title and 350-word abstract for my talk, which I’m planning to write up as a chapter in my second book.

    “Corpus of Chaos: Headbanging to Conventional Form Cues in Meshuggah’s Unconventional Songs”

    Meshuggah’s extreme metal songs often have disorienting forms, which eschew conventional verse-chorus teleology (Nobile 2022), instead staging a progression of static sections, creating seemingly intractable expanses of time. And yet, their audiences all seem to know when to start moshing, and when their song forms are written down, their proportions often strongly resemble metal’s normative song form, compound AABA (Hudson 2021). How is it that song form which look so conventional on paper can feel so disorienting in listening?

    To answer this question, I build on theories of metal drumming and song form—which often foreground affordances for physical participation. Traditional theories of pop song form focus on section types determined by lyrics (“verse,” “chorus,” etc.) but metal fans experience also experience form implicitly through embodied feeling and active motion, such as headbanging and moshing. Metal’s riff-based version of compound AABA structures this participatory listening by offering fans both specific formal cues, especially drum patterns (Kozak 2021; Garza 2021; Hudson 2022), and familiar patterns of song form that organize physical engagement, especially buildup intros, verse-chorus “energy cycles” (Pillsbury 2006), transforming or transporting bridges (Hudson 2023), half-time breakdowns (Gamble 2019), and vamps. In this way metal song forms create ritual spaces for heaviness, by implicitly choreographing participatory dance to create shared moments of physical impact (Hudson 2026, Chapter 9).

    I use this conventional framework to analyze Meshuggah’s unconventional song forms, showing how they retain some familiar cues and patterns while also departing from these norms. Several of Meshuggah’s most well-known songs follow a pattern of two verse cycles followed by a bridge, with a guitar solo occurring roughly two-thirds of the way through the song’s duration—just like compound AABA (Example 1). However, most of Meshuggah’s songs do not have the conventional teleology of a quieter verse leading up to a louder chorus; instead they alternate, without a sense of directionality or hierarchy, between verses and what I call “pseudo-choruses.” I show how even Meshuggah’s most experimental songs often retain some conventional formal cues (especially drum pattern shifts and guitar solos) which guide listeners’ participatory movement, shaping shared experiences of heaviness.

  • A Way out (Unifaun, 2008)

    Same old question: should we like bands like Unifaun that explicitly revive classic prog bands’ style? Well, the answer is simple to me: yes, if they know how to write good songs and to play them. This is the case with Swedish duo Unifaun, whose only album to date include some very good and very Genesis oriented songs. This Swedish duo includes singer and multi-instrumentalist Nad Sylvan of Steve Hackett live band fame and keyboardist Christian Thordin, AKA Bonamici. 


    Above: the dark original 2008 cover art. Below: the Genesis-oriented 2023 reissue painting.

    Their self-titled album features many musical solutions related to the ex Charterhouse pupils, but with a distinctive nordic and slightly folk taste I appreciate. The track I choose here is a prog ballad full of dreamy passages and based on really good melodies. The overall effect is mostly similar to Genesis’ “Selling England by The Pound” era. Is this a good reason to despise such a song? I don’t think so, but let me know your opinions.

  • In Concert: Glenn Hughes with Sophie Lloyd

    by Emma Jenkins– Guest Journalist — Rock City in Nottingham, England – October 24, 2025 Sophie Lloyd opened her set with the unmistakable “Top Gun” theme, setting the tone for an evening driven by high‑octane […]
  • Kontraster (Jordsjø, 2025)

    Here you are another Norwegian brilliant band, progging away between pure symphonic rock, folk hints and some experimental, even dissonant moments. Jordsjø released their first album in 2015 and this track comes from a 2025 split record including this Jordsjø’s title track on vinyl version side A and another side-long track by Breidablik, an electronic prog project by Morten Birkeland Nielsen on side B. “Kontraster” (“Contrasts”, in English) does as its title says and offers an awesome variety of moods, arrangements, instruments and musical ideas. 

    This is the second joint venture of Jordsjø and Breidablik.

    It is a rather low tempo collection – maybe a suite – of inner reflections and by such a rich palette you could hardly guess that  Jordsjø is formed by just two musicians: multi-instrumentalist Håkon Oftung and percussionist Kristian Frøland. Be as it may, this duo leads the listener through a fantastic and unpredictable trip, flowing very deep inside their souls (our souls, I daresay). It is an enriching and entertaining listening, something you won’t easily find nowadays.

  • Wake up (Coheed And Cambria, 2005)

    I know, I know… Coheed and Cambria are famous for their long, hard and intricate tracks, with fast electric guitar and keyboard solos… and after all they’re among the best prog metal acts out there! So I apologise for choosing one of their slow tempo and rather acoustic ballads for my blog, but some of you may know how mellow I can be and – most of all – I like this track so much. Many metal and even more-than-metal bands come up with love songs from time to time and when they do so, they’re so sweet and sappy than yhey make the likes of Barry Manilow or the Carpenters sound harsh. 

    As the number suggests, this album is part of a longer SF concept.

    This is not the case with “Wake up” here: it surely is a lovely ballad, but it never goes maudlin and everything in it has an edgy side: the vocals, the guitar touch, even the lyrics, so that the listener swings between love and loneliness, hope and fear all along the song. That said, the main virtue of this track obviously is its melody, so lovely and nonetheless never too predictable. What else? Just enjoy.

  • North (John Lees’ Barclay James Harvest, 2013)

     Maybe John Lees’ version of BJH doesn’t change the story of his original band, band he still knows how to write beautiful songs and this is the case with the title track of JL-BJH’s 2013 album. The usual pastoral sound is there, along with a tense musical background and – of course – a beutiful guitar solo. Most of all, the tune flows fresh and nice, and the instrumental parts are simply perfect. 

    “North” was the first studio album released with the moniker 
    John Lees’ Barclay James Harvest

    The way Mr. Lees regales his listeners by adding new ideas and lushing interludes always amazes me. Just try this track’s coda: it’s like following Alice into a musical Wonderland, in my humble opinion. The apparent simplicity of those songs underlines the skills of both the composer and the performers and that’s why such a song really can light up a dull day.

  • Lady Time (Numen, 1998)

    Numen are a Spanish band whose musical consistency, so far from any commercial benefits and strongly rooted in the neo-prog soil, I surely appreciate. Since their debut album “Samsara” they displayed a nice bend for melodies and considerable instrumental skills. This song comes precisely from “Samsara” and I know many of you would have singled out other and more complex compositions from this album… but I hope you’ll forgive me as you know how much I like a well done and well played pastoral song.

    Didn’t I say that Numen also like beautiful artworks for their releases?

    This is exacly the case with “Lady Time”, where a well found theme lies on a smooth sonic carpet and the listener can also find some beautiful guitar solos and a delicious flute work. Furthermore, there is a very clever and unpredictable change of mood around minute 3:25, when the Camel-esque pastoral song becomes more Marillion-esque and, believe me, this is simply perfect for my ears. 

  • The Bryden 2-Step (for Amphibians) Part 1 + Part 2 (National Health, 1978)

    National Health is one of the most intricate and jazzy Canterbury Scene bands, strictly linked to Hatfield And The North, keyboardist Dave Stewart’s band from 1973 to 1975 after his previous experiences with Egg and Khan, but also drummer Pip Pyle’s and guitarist Phil Miller’s ex band. For their 1978 album “Of Queues And Cures”, National Health also included multi-instrumentalist John Greaves of Henry Cow fame. The two parts of The Bryden 2-Step (for Amphibians) respectively open and close this record and are two splendid specimens of Canterbury sound, mixing up melodies, jazz-rock passages and folk-rock elements in a warm, diversified and intricate structure. 

    A real cabinet of curiosities…

    The two sections are rather different in mood (the first one being more up-tempo and jazz oriented than the second one), but there is a strong consistency between them, reinforced by the recurring main theme and the presence of the same guest musicians: Phil Minton (trumpets), Paul Nieman (trombones) and Georgie Born (cello), whose instruments give a wider sonic landscape to this split suite. A special mention goes to the main theme, one of the most charming Canterbury-branded compositions ever and to the constant search for originality throughout these overall 13 minutes of unpredictable music.