The worst rock singers of all time can be a very peculiar situation. They might be poor or downright bad in isolation. However, when combined with the right music and approach, they can shine. This has been seen time and time again throughout the history of music.
Having said that, though, this doesn’t mean the following vocalists were good on their own, which is going to be the focus of this list. It is also worth pointing out that this list is subjective and doesn’t intend to disrespect these people.
1. Johnny Rotten
It is ironic that one of the most iconic bands in history has one of the worst rock singers of all time. Johnny Rotten was the vocalist of the Sex Pistols during the band’s heyday in the 70s, singing some of the United Kingdom‘s most iconic rock anthems of its generation. However, that doesn’t mean that he was a good singer.
The band only made one record, 1977’s “Never Mind the Bollocks, Here’s the Sex Pistols“, which became an instant classic in the genre. Rotten‘s singing, on the other hand, was weak, lacking technique, and without any range whatsoever. Yes, there was certainly a lot of attitude, which was a major selling point of punk, but that doesn’t make him a great singer.
This is one of those cases where the vocalist fits with the musical ethos of the band, but it doesn’t mean that he is great on his own. If he were playing a cleaner music style, one that relied a lot more on melody, Rotten wouldn’t have been given the time of day.
2. Dave Mustaine
Dave Mustaine has had one of the most successful careers in rock. Having been fired by Metallica when the latter were starting to release records, he managed to recover from that and enjoy a lot of success on his own with Megadeth. It is an even bigger achievement that he managed to do this despite being one of the worst rock singers of his generation.
Now, this is not to say that Megadeth doesn’t have great music, anyway. And they made it work with Mustaine as a vocalist. However, it is also true that his voice is simply not easy on the ear. It is scratchy, the nasal tone can be quite grating, and doesn’t have the most melodic of approaches. Sometimes the songs can sound quite hard to enjoy because of it.
There is also the fact that aging and years of substance abuse have taken a toll on Mustaine‘s vocal range. This is something that can be heard on the more recent Megadeth albums and tours. So, all of these situations give more context to the struggles he went through as a singer.
3. Vince Neil
It’s common knowledge that Vince Neil is one of the worst rock singers of his generation. This may sound harsh, but it is a reality that even Motley Crue fans have come to accept. While his performances in the 80s albums of the band were decent enough, they never compared to other vocalists of the decade’s hard rock scene. His nasal tone, coupled with his lack of power when singing, has always been the subject of criticism.
All of this is focused on his studio performances, though. When it comes to the live shows, he fares even worse. It has become a running joke how much Neil struggles when performing live in recent years, but that was already an issue during Motley Crue‘s prime. The biggest difference is that time and excess have taken a major toll on his performances as well.
There is an argument to be made that Neil was what the band needed at the time. However, when considering how much Motley Crue improved musically with singer John Corabi during the 1994 self-titled album, there is an argument to be made that Neil wasn’t that essential. If anything, he was the easiest member to replace, based on his contributions.
4. Bob Dylan
There is no denying that Bob Dylan is one of the greatest to ever do it. One of the all-time greats in music. However, there is the paradox that he is also one of the worst rock singers. But this is a case where an interesting debate is raised.
See, Dylan‘s voice isn’t naturally beautiful. From a sound perspective, he is very likely a poor singer. He doesn’t have the most melodic of voices and can’t give you catchy lines like some of the best vocalists out there. And that is something that can be seen as a huge problem. However, there is the counterargument that he excels at conveying emotion and has amazing phrasing. Therefore, this debate can bring up a lot of questions regarding what makes a singer.
From a technical perspective, Bob Dylan isn’t a good voice. Moreover, there is a very good chance that his voice is going to be either loved or hated by a newcomer. It is a matter of personal taste, just like with any other singer on this list. However, there is no denying that he doesn’t have the greatest of voices, which can be a problem for some new listeners. At the end of the day, we all have our own preferences.
5. Anthony Kiedis
The fact that Kiedis has mentioned that he has had a lot of vocal coaches and none of them has managed to help him says a lot. As mentioned in the introduction, being one of the worst rock singers doesn’t mean that you can’t fit well within a band. Kiedis‘ stint with Red Hot Chili Peppers is a prime example of that. There is even a strong argument to be made that he is perfect for the band.
However, that doesn’t mean that he is a great singer. During the early days of the band, he was mostly focused on rapping, which got the job done. It wasn’t the greatest, but it added a flair of innovation for a rock band at the time. But as Kiedis was attempting to sing more melodically, which is something that can be seen in the late 90s and onward, the weaknesses of his voice began to show.
There is also the fact that, like other singers on this list, Kiedis struggled massively on stage. He often had difficulties living up to the quality of the records. And that is the mark of a poor singer. However, it is also worth pointing out that he still managed to thrive with the band. So, at the end of the day, who are we to judge him?
6. David Lee Roth
There is a reason why producer Ted Templeman wanted Sammy Hagar as Van Halen‘s vocalist all the way back during the recording of their 1978 self-titled debut. The producer’s concern was that singer David Lee Roth wasn’t good enough to live up to the task. And being absolutely fair with Templeman, even though he stuck with Roth, he had a point.
A major reason why Roth is one of the worst rock singers is because of his lack of range and inconsistency. When it comes to the range, he struggles greatly to add diversity to the band’s musical palette. And when it comes to the inconsistency, he struggles to stay on key a lot of times. While the first Van Halen could be considered one of the vocalist’s best performances, he still has a hard time staying on key.
This is something that was reflected during the band’s live performances. His singing was not up to the required standard and he was usually struggling with the higher notes. Moreover, during Van Halen‘s prime, alcohol and substance abuse also played a role in his performances. The 1983 US Festival is arguably the best example of this when it comes to Roth.
7. Janis Joplin
No disrespect to Janis Joplin as a person since she passed away. But there is no denying that she is one of the worst rock singers of all time. Her legacy is, in a way, defined by her death. She passed away young, with an entire future ahead of her, and that kept her in a somewhat sacred status. However, that has kept people from having a serious discussion about her musical acumen, which wasn’t of the highest caliber.
Joplin‘s voice lacked the power and emotional intensity to compensate for such a raspy tone. While other female rock singers took this singing style and elevated it, with her, it is merely an annoyance. It is a shame because you hear her singing and you can tell there was potential. However, due to her sudden passing, that potential was never seized. And what was left was a lot of uninspired, overrated vocal performances.
This is one of those cases where the mystique comes from the legacy, not the quality of the work. If anything, Joplin comes off as merely another rock and roll singer of the late 60s, albeit without the quality. It happens and it is a shame.
8 . Paul Stanley
Paul Stanley might be the best representation of KISS as a whole. None of the members of the original lineup was a virtuoso. However, what they lack in technique, they make up with songwriting and sheer charisma. If classic KISS has something, it is charisma. And it is something that can be seen time and time again with Stanley‘s singing.
He might not be the biggest offender among the worst rock singers, but he is certainly up there. His rough vocals sometimes struggle to fit with the rather melodic approach of the songs. Furthermore, this is complemented by the fact that he has a track record of struggling in live performances. The lack of versatility with his singing can also be seen in the many times KISS has changed music styles.
Paul Stanley is still a rock legend. That can’t be put into question. However, there is also no denying that he is not one of the best singers out there. And that’s fine! He compensated with other virtues. That’s also worth taking into account.
9. Fred Durst
The case of Fred Durst is interesting because he actually fits Limp Bizkit‘s rap side quite well. He manages to make it work and their rap metal style flows well because of Durst himself. However, he becomes one of the worst rock singers when he tries a more traditional vocal style.
There are instances throughout Limp Bizkit‘s career where he has attempted clean singing and it simply doesn’t work. He doesn’t have the range, he can’t convey emotion very well, and overall is a bit mediocre when it comes to this. Durst simply doesn’t have the ability to be a versatile singer, unlike, say, Corey Taylor from Slipknot and Stone Sour.
This is an example of a singer who struggles because of a playing style that demands him to be versatile. And Fred Durst simply doesn’t have it in him.
10. Kid Rock
Kid Rock is one of the worst rock singers because of his poor live performances. This is something that was recently seen during Turning Point USA’s “All-American” halftime show this last February, where he was performing so poorly that they had to use lip-syncing. That’s how bad it got for him.
Furthermore, this has been a running issue throughout the band’s career. He has always struggled in translating the studio material to the stage, which has hurt his prospects in the long run. It is a pattern that has only gotten worse for him when it comes to his live performances due to aging as well.
In that regard, Kid Rock is an example of aging and not taking care of himself. It happens to even the best out there. However, he is still one of the worst rock singers in the business as of this writing. The fact that he exposed himself that way is a testament to that.
The post 10 of the Worst Singers in Rock History appeared first on Metal Shout.
