
Brady Ebert, who co-founded Turnstile and played guitar on all three of their albums, has been ruled mentally incompetent to stand trial on attempted murder charges. Montgomery County Circuit Court Judge Karla Smith made the ruling on Tuesday and found Ebert a danger to himself and others, remanding him to the custody of the Maryland Department of Health. The trial had been due to start this week. Ebert is accused of striking William Yates, the 79-year-old father of Turnstile frontman Brendan Yates, with a car earlier this year in Silver Spring, and he denies the charges. His competency will be reviewed at a hearing on 19 January 2027.
STREAM THE METAL BREAKDOWN DAILY NOW:
Scott Penfold breaks down the latest hard rock and metal news stories on today’s Metal Breakdown Daily. Download the free Loaded Radio App on Apple iOS and Google Play and stream the show now.
What The Judge Ruled
Judge Smith’s finding does two things. It says Ebert can’t currently take part in his own defence, and it puts him into state health custody rather than jail while that’s addressed.
His trial had been set for 25 September. It won’t happen. The next date is 19 January 2027, when the court will look at whether his competency has been restored.
The hearing itself was difficult. Ebert argued with the judge and was removed from the courtroom by officers after an outburst, according to reporting from The Baltimore Banner and Metal Injection. He has said the case against him is an ‘extreme miscarriage of justice’ and has accused police of obtaining his arrest warrant illegally.
His attorney, Mark Sobel, put it plainly outside the ruling. ‘Hopefully, he’ll get the proper treatment for his competency to be restored, so we can proceed to trial in this case,’ he said.
LIVE & LOUD: Stream the World’s Hardest Radio Station 24/7
This Is Not A Verdict, And The Case Isn’t Over
Worth being clear about, because it’s the part people get wrong.
Being found incompetent to stand trial has nothing to do with guilt or innocence. It’s a finding about whether a defendant can understand the proceedings and help their own lawyer right now. The charges stay in place. If competency is restored, the case goes to trial.
Ebert remains in custody, at a state health facility rather than a detention centre.
The Allegation
According to charging documents reported by The Baltimore Banner, Ebert drove at William Yates on a residential street in Silver Spring, Maryland earlier this year, then reversed, accelerated and struck him, leaving him with serious injuries to his lower legs.
Ebert faces attempted murder and related charges, and he was held without bond after his arrest. We covered the arrest when it happened and again when the charge was upgraded.
Ebert has denied all of it. He has called the police report a lie and said he acted in self defence. None of the allegations has been tested at trial, and now they won’t be for months.
Investigators were told by William Yates that Ebert had been in contact with the family repeatedly since the band split with him. His daughter told reporters that Ebert had been causing problems for them since he was removed from Turnstile.
Who Brady Ebert Is
Ebert started Turnstile in 2010 with Brendan Yates, Franz Lyons and Daniel Fang, in the Baltimore hardcore scene. He was on all three records: Nonstop Feeling, Time & Space and Glow On, the 2021 album that took the band from hardcore matinees to festival main stages and the Grammys.
The split came on 13 August 2022. The band’s statement was short: ‘Turnstile and guitarist Brady Ebert are parting ways. We are deeply grateful for our time together. Our love for him continues and we wish him nothing but the best moving forward.’ No reason was given, then or since. His last performance with them was a Jimmy Kimmel Live taping in March 2022.
Turnstile have kept climbing since. They took home two Grammys in February, which put them at the centre of the argument about heavy music and the awards, and they’re one of the bands behind hardcore’s move into the mainstream.
The band has not commented on the case.
What Happens Next
Ebert stays in the care of the Maryland Department of Health. Doctors there assess whether his competency can be restored with treatment. On 19 January the court reviews where that stands.
Three things can follow. Competency is restored and the case goes to trial. It isn’t restored and the review continues. Or, if it can’t be restored over a long enough period, the court considers other options under Maryland law, including civil commitment.
None of that is a resolution for the Yates family, who are months into this with a 79-year-old man recovering from a serious injury and no trial in sight.
TL;DR
- Brady Ebert, co-founder and former guitarist of Turnstile, has been ruled incompetent to stand trial.
- Judge Karla Smith of Montgomery County Circuit Court also found him a danger to himself and others, and remanded him to the Maryland Department of Health.
- He’s accused of striking William Yates, the 79-year-old father of Turnstile singer Brendan Yates, with a car in Silver Spring, Maryland earlier this year. He denies it.
- The ruling is not a verdict. The charges stand, and the trial set for 25 September is off.
- His competency will be reviewed on 19 January 2027.
FAQ
What does incompetent to stand trial mean?
It means the court has found the defendant unable to understand the proceedings against them or to help their own attorney with a defence. It is not a finding of guilt or innocence, and the charges remain in place. If competency is restored, the case can proceed to trial.
What is Brady Ebert charged with?
Ebert faces attempted murder and related charges over an incident in Silver Spring, Maryland earlier this year. He has denied the charges and said he acted in self defence.
Is Brady Ebert still in Turnstile?
No. Ebert co-founded Turnstile in 2010 and played on all three of the band’s albums. Turnstile announced they had parted ways with him on 13 August 2022, without giving a reason.
What happens to Brady Ebert now?
He has been remanded to the custody of the Maryland Department of Health for treatment. A hearing on 19 January 2027 will review whether his competency has been restored.
Have Turnstile commented on the case?
No. The band has not made any public statement about the charges or the competency ruling.
This one is grim from every angle, and a 79-year-old man is still recovering. What do you make of the ruling? Keep it respectful in the comments. Follow Loaded Radio for daily rock and metal news.
The post Ex-Turnstile Guitarist Ruled Mentally Incompetent For Trial In Attempted Murder Case appeared first on Loaded Radio.