If you haven’t checked out Italian prog rock band Karmamoi yet, their 7th album, Eternal Mistake, is your opportunity. Taking inspiration from bands like latter-day Porcupine Tree, which blend edgy riffs with emotion and lush arrangements, this quartet has plenty of musical muscle alongside intriguing lyrical ideas. Indeed, Eternal Mistake is a concept album set not very far into the future, where a romance between a human and a humanoid is possible. Taking the template of Frankenstein and adding a dash of romance, we explore a few of the profound themes surrounding AI and its implications for emotions, soul, and love.
Given the subject material, it’s refreshing to see the disclaimer “AI-Free Statement: Music, Lyrics, Arrangements, Mixing, and Artwork of ‘Eternal Mistake’ are AI-free” boldly declared at the outset. Hopefully, many bands will adopt this approach too, and keep our music human-made. (Though what then comes to mind are the many 70s Queen albums which proudly declared being made devoid of synths…only to later swing dramatically in the opposite direction. Machines…back to humans!)
Whether you’re looking for a creative, futuristic concept storyline or not, Eternal Mistake has plenty to offer from a musical perspective as well. Impressively, the album launches with one banger track after another. Aside from the melodic hooks, what stands out most are the thickly layered arrangements, which juxtapose emotional vocal delivery with chordal progressions that suck you in.
Singer Valerio Sgargi thankfully has a great set of pipes, which are able to even lend an occasional operatic flair when the storyline requires it, a la Devin Townsend or Damian Wilson. With vocals often being the weak link for modern prog bands, it’s gratifying to savor the power and assuredness of a strong singer. Sgargi, who also plays keys and guitar, collaborates with drummer/keyboardist Daniele Giovannoni on all of the material, and apparently, they are a strong team together because the resulting songs deliver time and time again. The band is rounded out by Alex Massari on guitars and Alessandro Cefalì on bass, both of whom bring a confident attitude and performance. It’s a dynamite collection of musicians, occasionally augmented by guest cameos.
The downside of a concept piece like this is that it can take itself a little too seriously, and at times, that can become overbearing or just corny. For the most part, this element only crops up during the bookends: the short opening narrated intro and the closing track. Don’t let them dissuade you, as there’s plenty of gold in between. “Lara Is Your Name” is a dramatic first proper song, bestowing our humanoid with her identity and providing a killer groove in which to do so. Giovannoni’s command of the drum kit is quickly apparent and is well engineered by Fabio Ferri. Throughout the album, Ferri utilizes some very cool techniques in his mix, which don’t distract but rather elevate the listening experience.

The next track, “Don’t Knock On The Door,” begins with a moody atmosphere but turns out to be a favorite on the album, so strong are its melodies and textures, not to mention Sgargi’s vocal impact. Sgargi and Giovannoni understand how to build a track over time, and the payoff is huge. “I’m Not On Your Side” picks up the pace with rough edges and a welcome slam on Trump’s egoistic bravado. But then we’re back to a mellow acoustic intro for “Nothing But”, proving that Karmamoi can succeed in all extremes of their dynamic range, as the song builds with a hypnotic performance over 10 minutes in length.
The existential dilemma of the story starts to dive deeper on the subsequent tracks with titles like “The Mirror”, “No Soul”, “The Question”, and the title track. Humanoid Lara wrestles with the inevitable questions of what home, love, and soul really mean for an artificial entity, especially in the context of a relationship. It’s an ideal backdrop for Sgargi to let it rip vocally, especially on “No Soul”, which even gets bluesy tones added to the mix, including Massari’s killer guitar soloing. One of the album’s best.
The tension continues building through an incredible duet with Susanna Brigatti on “We Are Going Home”, another highlight. Wow. Simply gorgeous. This could easily be the finale of the album, as it is such a fulfilling song and feels like a crescendo, but the band continues with the 10-minute “Hero”, finding Giovannoni going to town on the drum kit.
The band’s attraction to Steven Wilson’s imprint is evident in their music – including the drumming – but they go a step further by inviting Adam Holzman and Randy McStine to cameo for keyboard and guitar solos, respectively. While a cool tip of the hat to these wizards, it also must be said that it feels unnecessary. To their credit, the band’s personnel has enough chops that they don’t really need any outside influence, and so it’s a little bit of a distraction. But it must have been satisfying for them to get that inclusion from these musicians, so no foul there.
Unfortunately, the album starts to deliver diminishing returns towards the end. Rather than choosing to close on the emotionally bonding note of “We Are Going Home”, the band instead ends the album with a track called “No Fucking Way”. Okay, then. Perhaps they felt the storyline had to continue this far, but to these ears it would have been a stronger album if the ending came a little sooner, with one or two fewer tracks. As it is, the album runs 104 minutes, which just feels a bit long.
Still, the ending doesn’t take away from the strength of the album as a whole. Eternal Mistake is unquestionably a success, despite what its title implies. This is an album that deserves to be discovered by the prog masses, a gem of ’26.
Release Date: April 17th, 2026
Record Label: Independent
Genre: Progressive Rock
Musicians:
- Daniele Giovannoni / Drums, keyboards, backing vocals
- Valerio Sgargi / Vocals, keyboards, guitars
- Alex Massari / Guitars
- Alessandro Cefalì / Bass
Eternal Mistake Tracklist:
- The Regrets
- Lara Is Your Name
- Don’t Knock On The Door
- I’m Not On Your Side
- Nothing But
- The Mirror
- No Soul
- Eternal Mistake
- The Question – We Are Going Home
- HERO
- Passing Away
- No Fucking Way
Order the album here.
The post KARMAMOI – Eternal Mistake (Album Review) appeared first on Sonic Perspectives.
Out May 8, 2026 Via Equal Vision Records/ Civilians Words by: Arlena Laessaari In a punk scene where lineups change constantly, sticking together for 24 years is a massive achievement. Canadian punk veterans The Flatliners, from Richmond Hill, Ontario, are living proof of that stability. The four lifelong friends Chris Cresswell, Scott Brigham, Jon Darbey, […]
If you love this music: 