
Ranking Anthrax means picking a side in an argument that has run for thirty-three years, because this is the only band in the Big Four with two beloved singers and no consensus about either of them. Twelve studio albums, three vocalists, a decade-long gap that just ended, and a fanbase that will fight you in a car park over 1993. This is every Anthrax album ranked worst to best, with the criteria stated before we start.
The criteria
The songs. Front to back, and how much of it you actually go back to.
What it did at the time. Whether the record moved anything — for the band, for thrash, for anyone who came after.
The production. Anthrax have been sabotaged by their own mixes more than once and it counts.
What it does now. On at volume in 2026, does it still work.
And one thing this list refuses to do: treat the John Bush era as a footnote. Nine years, four albums, their highest-charting record and their best-selling one. Any ranking that buries all of it below every Belladonna album isn’t ranking music, it’s ranking nostalgia. If that annoys you, wait until number three.
Loaded Radio Recommends — The 13 Best Thrash Metal Bands, Voted By You
12. Fistful of Metal (1984)

Best song: “Metal Thrashing Mad” Why it’s last: It’s a different band with a different singer, and you can hear them working out what they’re for.
The debut, and the only Anthrax album fronted by Neil Turbin. Produced on almost nothing, mixed thin, and sung in a high, wailing register that has almost nothing to do with what Anthrax became eighteen months later.
There’s real stuff on it. “Metal Thrashing Mad” is a genuine early thrash statement and “Death from Above” has the riffs. The Alice Cooper cover is a curiosity that tells you exactly which decade they came out of.
But it’s last because it’s a prototype. Dan Spitz had only just joined, Frank Bello wasn’t in the band yet, and the thing that makes Anthrax Anthrax — the New York hardcore swing underneath the thrash, the sense of humour, the melody — isn’t there yet.
Essential if you’re tracing how thrash actually got built. Not something you put on.
11. Volume 8: The Threat Is Real (1998)

Best song: “Inside Out” Why it’s here: Good songs, no album, and the label collapsed underneath it.
The most unlucky record in the catalogue. Volume 8 came out on Ignition Records, which went bankrupt almost immediately, and an album that needed promotion to find its audience simply vanished.
That’s the context. The content is genuinely patchy. “Inside Out” is one of the best things Bush ever sang, “Crush” has a monstrous riff, and Phil Anselmo turns up on “Killing Box.” Then there are the acoustic detours and the industrial textures that sound like a band throwing everything at a wall in 1998 because everybody else was.
Eleventh, not because Bush is on it, but because it’s the one Anthrax record where you can hear the strategy instead of the songs.
10. State of Euphoria (1988)

Best song: “Antisocial” Why it’s here: The follow-up to their masterpiece, made too fast and mixed too clean.
This is the placement that’ll annoy the people who grew up on “Antisocial,” so let me be clear: that song is enormous, it’s still in the set, and the Trust cover is better than the original.
The album around it is the problem. Charlie Benante has himself said they rushed it, and it sounds rushed — writing done on tour, a mix that sands the edges off, and a running order that puts the two best songs early and then wanders. “Be All, End All” is great. “Who Cares Wins” drags.
Coming eighteen months after Among the Living was always going to be brutal. Making it in a hurry made it worse.
9. Stomp 442 (1995)

Best song: “Fueled” Why it’s here: Underrated, genuinely good, and slighter than the record before it.
Stomp 442 has the worst reputation-to-quality ratio in the catalogue. It arrived into the middle of Elektra losing interest, got almost no push, and is the album most Anthrax fans have never properly sat with.
It’s lean and mean — stripped-back, groove-heavy, and Dimebag Darrell plays on it, which for 1995 was the strongest possible endorsement. “Fueled” and “Random Acts of Senseless Violence” would sit comfortably on any of the records above it.
Ninth because it’s short on ideas rather than short on quality. After the ambition of Sound of White Noise, this is a band consolidating rather than pushing, and it’s also the album where Dan Spitz’s departure left them without a lead guitarist.
8. For All Kings (2016)

Best song: “Breathing Lightning” Why it’s here: Everything works and nothing surprises.
The second Belladonna-reunion album, with Jonathan Donais of Shadows Fall now settled in on lead, and it’s a properly made, properly played thrash record by a band who know exactly what they are.
“Breathing Lightning” is the standout and “Evil Twin” has genuine bite. The production, by Jay Ruston, is the best-sounding Anthrax album in decades — you can hear Benante’s kick drum, which on a couple of these records you cannot.
Eighth because it’s the safest thing here. Worship Music had the drama of a reunion behind it. For All Kings is what a good Anthrax album sounds like when there’s nothing at stake, and that’s a lower ceiling.
7. Cursum Perficio (2026)

Best song: “The Edge Of Perfection” Why it’s here: A genuinely strong record that hasn’t had time to prove it lasts.
Their twelfth album, out via Nuclear Blast after a decade-long gap — only their fourth album of new material in twenty-five years, which tells you how the last ten years went. Scott Ian spent some of it in the reborn Mr. Bungle. Charlie Benante spent some of it drumming in Pantera.
Eleven tracks, same settled lineup that’s held for a decade.
“The Edge Of Perfection” is the reason it places this high. Nearly seven minutes, melodic, ambitious, and Dom Lawson called it arguably the finest song the band have written since Belladonna’s return in 2011. Scott Ian’s lyric is about the pitfalls and the crescendos of a long loving life, which is a very long way from Judge Dredd and a considerably braver place for a thrash band to go at this stage.
Elsewhere: “It’s For the Kids” is straight speed and the best pure thrash moment, “Everybody’s Got A Plan” is prime late-period Anthrax with Belladonna sounding ageless, and “NYC 93” and “Watch It Go” are the two most genuinely original things they’ve released in years.
The wobble is the front end. “The Long Goodbye” is a mid-paced opener that takes several listens to reveal itself, and “Infectious” and “T.O.M.B.” are slow-burners rather than adrenalin. On a thrash record, sequencing the patient songs early is a risk.
Seventh, provisionally. Ask me in 2029. If “The Edge Of Perfection” is still in the set and people are still arguing about it, this climbs.
6. Worship Music (2011)

Best song: “Fight ‘Em Till You Can’t” Why it’s here: The comeback that had no business working, and did.
Eight years in the making, two singers hired and unhired along the way, and then Belladonna back after nearly two decades. On paper it’s a disaster. In practice it’s the best Anthrax album since 1993.
“Fight ‘Em Till You Can’t” is one of the great late-period thrash songs — fast, furious, hooky, and built entirely for a room full of people. “In the End” is their tribute to Dio and Dimebag and it’s genuinely moving rather than dutiful. “The Devil You Know” still opens sets.
Sixth because the back half loosens and because Worship Music is a great comeback rather than a great album full stop. But it re-established them as a going concern and everything after it exists because this worked.
5. We’ve Come for You All (2003)

Best song: “Safe Home” Why it’s here: The Bush era’s proper goodbye, and one of the most complete records in the catalogue.
If you only know the Bush years by reputation, this is the album that ends the argument about whether they were any good.
“Safe Home” is the most fully-realised song Anthrax have written — melodic, enormous, and sung by a man who could do things Belladonna can’t. Dimebag Darrell plays on two tracks, including his last recorded guest appearances with them before his death the following year. “What Doesn’t Die” and “Superhero” both belong in any career-spanning set.
Fifth, and it’s the placement I’d defend second-hardest after number three. It’s more consistent than Worship Music and better written than anything in the bottom half. What keeps it out of the top four is that it arrived at the exact moment nobody was listening — Rob Caggiano’s first album, a label in trouble again, and an audience who’d moved on.
4. Spreading the Disease (1985)

Best song: “Madhouse” Why it’s here: Where Anthrax became Anthrax, and it’s still in the top four of anybody’s list.
Belladonna’s first album, Frank Bello’s first album, and the record where all the pieces arrive at once. “Madhouse” is the moment — that riff, that vocal, that sense that thrash could have a melody without softening. “A.I.R.” and “Gung-Ho” are both relentless. “Medusa” is criminally under-played.
It’s the album that separated them from the pack: faster than Metallica were being at the time, more tuneful than Slayer, and with a rhythmic swing that came out of New York hardcore rather than the Bay Area.
Fourth, which will read as low to a lot of people, and that’s entirely down to the next entry.
3. Sound of White Noise (1993)

Best song: “Only” Why it’s here: Their best-selling album, their highest-charting album, and the one the fanbase refuses to rank properly.
Here’s the argument, so let’s have it out.
John Bush’s first Anthrax album debuted at number seven on the Billboard 200 — the highest chart position the band has ever achieved — and went gold. Those aren’t opinions.
And then there’s “Only.” Dimebag Darrell called it a perfect song, which is about the highest compliment available in this genre from that source, and he was right. It has a riff, a chorus, a middle eight and a vocal performance that no thrash band in 1993 could have got near, and it still sounds enormous.
The rest of the album earns the placement without it. “Potters Field” opens it like a door coming off its hinges. “Black Lodge” was co-written with Angelo Badalamenti of Twin Peaks and it’s the strangest, most atmospheric thing Anthrax have ever recorded. “Hy Pro Glo” and “Packaged Rebellion” both work. Dave Jerden’s production gives it a low end and a physical weight that Persistence of Time and State of Euphoria simply don’t have.
So why does it get buried? Because Belladonna came back in 2010, and the moment he did, a chunk of the fanbase retroactively decided nine years and four albums didn’t count. That isn’t a musical judgement, it’s a loyalty one.
I’ll put it plainly. If this album had Joey Belladonna singing on it, it would be in everybody’s top three and nobody would blink. It’s the best-produced record Anthrax made, it’s their commercial peak, it contains their single best song, and it was brave — a thrash band in 1993 hiring the singer from Armored Saint and making a record that didn’t chase the trend in either direction.
Third, above Spreading the Disease, and I’d argue it all night.
2. Persistence of Time (1990)

Best song: “In My World” Why it’s here: The darkest, most ambitious thing they ever made.
After the rush of State of Euphoria, Anthrax took their time and made a record about anger, paranoia and time running out — and then a fire destroyed their rehearsal space and equipment while they were making it, which you can hear in the thing.
“In My World” is eight minutes of controlled dread. “Got the Time” is the Joe Jackson cover that became one of their signature songs and shouldn’t work at all. “Belly of the Beast,” “Keep It in the Family,” “Blood” — there’s no filler and no jokes.
It earned them a Grammy nomination and it’s the album critics reach for when they want to argue Anthrax were the most musically serious band in the Big Four.
Second, and if you told me it was first I wouldn’t put up much of a fight. The only thing above it is untouchable.
1. Among the Living (1987)

Best song: “Caught in a Mosh” Why it’s here: One of the five most important thrash albums ever made, and the most fun of them by a mile.
Nine songs. Forty-nine minutes. Not one wasted second.
“Caught in a Mosh” is the best song Anthrax ever wrote and possibly the best song in this entire subgenre — that riff, that stop-start, that vocal, and a chorus that a stadium can sing while actively injuring each other. Then “I Am the Law” about Judge Dredd, “Indians” with the war dance that still stops rooms, “Efilnikufesin (N.F.L.)” about John Belushi, and “Among the Living” about The Stand.
That’s the thing about this record. Every other Big Four band was angry. Anthrax were angry and having the time of their lives, and Among the Living is the only thrash album from that era you could put on at a party. The Stephen King references, the shorts, the skate art, the sense of humour — none of it makes it less heavy. Put “Caught in a Mosh” on at volume and the riff at 0:38 still takes the floor out.
It is also, straightforwardly, the album that taught hardcore kids it was fine to like metal and metal kids it was fine to like hardcore, and half of what came afterward exists because of that crossover.
Thirty-nine years on, nothing in this catalogue is close.
The three singers, because this is the actual argument
You cannot rank Anthrax without addressing it, so here it is straight.
Joey Belladonna sang on 1985’s Spreading the Disease through 1990’s Persistence of Time, was out from 1992 to 2010, and has been back since — seven of the twelve albums in total. He’s a genuine metal singer with genuine range, and he’s the voice of the era that made the band.
John Bush, of Armored Saint, sang on four albums from 1993 to 2003. He’s a lower, grittier, more soulful singer — closer to hard rock than thrash — and his arrival is the single most divisive decision this band ever made.
Neil Turbin sang on the 1984 debut and nothing else.
The honest position is that they’re not competing for the same job. Belladonna is the better fit for what Anthrax were built to be. Bush is the better singer of a certain kind of song, and “Only” and “Safe Home” are two of the five best things the band has ever put its name to.
Any ranking that puts all seven Belladonna albums above all four Bush albums is telling you about allegiance, not quality. Volume 8 is worse than State of Euphoria. Sound of White Noise is better than Spreading the Disease. Both of those are true and neither has anything to do with who’s holding the microphone.
Where this ranking will start arguments
Sound of White Noise at three is the whole page and I’ve made the case above. Highest-charting, best-selling, contains “Only,” and it gets buried for reasons that aren’t about the music.
Spreading the Disease at four follows from that. It’s a top-four album on any honest list and it’s here rather than higher because of what’s above it, not because of anything wrong with it.
State of Euphoria at ten will upset the “Antisocial” crowd. The song’s great. The album was made in a hurry and Benante has said so himself.
Cursum Perficio at seven is provisional and stated as such. New records need time.
Among the Living at one isn’t seriously contested, and I’ve never met anybody who’s lived with this catalogue and argued otherwise.
If you want more of this, the full Loaded Radio rankings archive is here, and the Megadeth discography is the natural companion.
Every Anthrax album, ranked
Anthrax albums in release order
Fistful of Metal — 1984 · Neil Turbin
Spreading the Disease — 1985 · Joey Belladonna
Among the Living — 1987 · Belladonna
State of Euphoria — 1988 · Belladonna
Persistence of Time — 1990 · Belladonna
Sound of White Noise — 1993 · John Bush
Stomp 442 — 1995 · Bush
Volume 8: The Threat Is Real — 1998 · Bush
We’ve Come for You All — 2003 · Bush
Worship Music — 2011 · Belladonna
For All Kings — 2016 · Belladonna
Cursum Perficio — 2026 · Belladonna
Seven with Belladonna. Four with Bush. One with Turbin.
Where Anthrax are now
Cursum Perficio lands this week via Nuclear Blast, ending a ten-year wait and marking only their fourth album of new material in a quarter of a century.
The lineup has been settled for a decade: Joey Belladonna, Scott Ian, Charlie Benante, Frank Bello and Jonathan Donais. Which is its own achievement for a band whose history is mostly personnel drama.
Both Ian and Benante have been busy elsewhere — Ian in the reformed Mr. Bungle, Benante behind the kit in Pantera — and the band have spent the gap doing what they do best, which is playing live to people who lose their minds. They remain, by a long way, the most enjoyable of the Big Four to stand in a room with.
Forty-two years, twelve albums, three singers, one Grammy nomination and a crossover legacy that runs through groove metal, metalcore and most of what came after.

TL;DR
- Twelve studio albums from 1984’s Fistful of Metal to 2026’s Cursum Perficio.
- Best: Among the Living (1987). Nine songs, no filler, “Caught in a Mosh,” and the only thrash album from that era you could put on at a party.
- Worst: Fistful of Metal (1984), the Neil Turbin debut — a prototype rather than an Anthrax album.
- The contested call: Sound of White Noise (1993) at number three. John Bush’s first album is their highest-charting and best-selling record, contains “Only,” and gets buried for reasons of allegiance rather than quality.
- The new one: Cursum Perficio at seven, provisionally. Blabbermouth gave it 8/10 and “The Edge Of Perfection” was called the best song they’ve written since Belladonna’s 2011 return.
- Three singers: Joey Belladonna on seven albums, John Bush on four, Neil Turbin on one.
- Ten-year gap between For All Kings and Cursum Perficio — only their fourth album of new material in twenty-five years.
FAQ
What is the best Anthrax album?
Among the Living, released in 1987. Nine songs with no filler, it contains “Caught in a Mosh,” “I Am the Law” and “Indians,” and is widely regarded as one of the most important thrash albums ever released. It’s also the record that pushed the crossover between metal and hardcore into the mainstream.
How many albums does Anthrax have?
Twelve studio albums: Fistful of Metal (1984), Spreading the Disease (1985), Among the Living (1987), State of Euphoria (1988), Persistence of Time (1990), Sound of White Noise (1993), Stomp 442 (1995), Volume 8: The Threat Is Real (1998), We’ve Come for You All (2003), Worship Music (2011), For All Kings (2016) and Cursum Perficio (2026).
Is the new Anthrax album any good?
Cursum Perficio has been well received — Blabbermouth scored it 8/10, with reviewer Dom Lawson describing “The Edge Of Perfection” as arguably the finest song the band have written since Joey Belladonna’s return in 2011. It ranks seventh here, a placement noted as provisional given the album’s only just arrived.
Which Anthrax singer is better, Joey Belladonna or John Bush?
They’re different singers suited to different material rather than rivals for the same role. Belladonna has the range and is the voice of the band’s defining era, appearing on seven albums. Bush is lower, grittier and more soulful, and sang on four albums including the band’s highest-charting record, Sound of White Noise, and “Only,” which Dimebag Darrell called a perfect song.
What is Anthrax’s best-selling album?
Sound of White Noise (1993), John Bush’s first album with the band, which debuted at number seven on the Billboard 200 — their highest chart placing — and was certified gold.
Twelve albums, three singers, and a Bush record in the top three. Have I lost my mind, or has everyone else been ranking this catalogue wrong for thirty years? Settle it in the comments. And keep it locked on the Loaded Radio stream — follow Loaded Radio for daily rock and metal news.
The post Anthrax Albums Ranked: All 12 From Worst To Best appeared first on Loaded Radio.

#11. Vol. 8 – The Threat is Real (1998) — The 90s saw Anthrax struggle for identity like most metal acts did. It was a decade that became unfriendly to metal as a genre, with grunge and alt-rock being the only things labels and radio stations wanted to know about. This forced bands to try to find their place in this new world order, and some managed better than others. Vol. 8 was the third album helmed by John Bush, and it was a troubled time for the band. The album very much sounds like the work of a group in search of a new direction, with various styles and ideas clashing badly. There are groove metal elements rubbing against straight-up thrash, alt-metal ideas, and nods to country rock for some unknown reason. Very little of it worked, and seriously, what the holy fook is with the country edge here? There are a few “hits” that stuck with me, like “Crush” and “Catharsis,” but so much of Vol. 8 is just forgettable filler, and this album still makes me scratch my head and wonder what the band was thinking. This barely qualifies as a demo, let alone an actual release from a band of their stature.
#10. We’ve Come for You All (2003) — This was the final release with Bush on vocals. At times it sounds like a flashback to The Sound of White Noise, and at others, it sounds tired and confused. It’s a slightly better showing than Vol. 8, though that isn’t saying much. You get a burner like “What Doesn’t Die” that makes you remember why you loved Anthrax in the first place, and “Safe Home” is a sneaky underdog that’s become one of my favorite metal anthems over the last 20 years. Sadly, the rest of the album sounds more like generic hard/alt rock akin to Audioslave or Seether than anything Anthrax-related. Be honest, do you ever want to hear any track off here besides the 2 mentioned prior? There are so many non-essential entries present that the whole thing ends up feeling washed out and badly forced. It was sad to see Bush go out like this, but things just weren’t working, and life is tough for him outside of Armored Saint.
#9. Stomp 442 (1995) — Since I came around on Sound of White Noise and learned to like, if not love, the Bush era of Anthrax, I came into Stomp 442 with a fairly open mind. I loved “Fueled” from jump, and it still sits on my workout and cardio playlists. It’s the superior “fuel” song to that other Big Four product, and it has way more punch and scrotal wattage. In fact, the directional shift in tone toward Pantera paid dividends for Anthrax, and there are a bunch of cuts here that are mean and gritty enough to win you over. “Random Acts of Senseless Violence” is a legit killer tune, “In a Zone” feels mean and hungry, and “Tester” would be a good song on any Thrax album. I even like the way things end on a tender note with “Bare.” It just feels right after all the raging, beefbrained riffing. This album gets way more hate than it deserves, and it’s only slightly lower in quality than Sound of White Noise. Give this another chance, and you might be surprised. Do it for Dimebag!
#8. Sound of White Noise (1993) — I remember hating the idea of John Bush joining Anthrax when it was announced. As a big fan of Armored Saint, I didn’t want to see them get wrecked to keep Anthrax aloft. When the lead single “Only” dropped, I was utterly unimpressed. I was working a night shift job when the album dropped, and the Siena College radio station ran a metal show after 11 PM that played the living hell out of Sound. Said airplay slowly wore me down to the point where I grudgingly accepted and ultimately enjoyed the album. It’s a consistent and entertaining record with a few big-ticket moments like “Room for One More” and “1000 Points of Hate.” “Black Lodge” has had legs over the years, and “C11 H17 N2 O2 S Na” is a very good tune as well. I don’t go back to Sound much these days since my true love is the Belladonna eras of Anthrax, but I do respect what the band pulled off here.
#7. Persistence of Time (1990) — I’m of the opinion that Persistence of Time may be one of the most overrated albums in metal history. It seems to be universally beloved, even by those who aren’t much into Anthrax, and I never understood why this one got placed so high on a pedestal. Yes, it’s the last release in the original Belladonna era, and yes, it’s darker than the prior Thrax albums, and sure, it’s good, but is it a great album? Not really. It has its good moments like “In My World” and “Belly of the Beast,” and their cover of Joe Jackson’s “Got the Time” has become an enduring staple of live shows. None of these are really “prime” Anthrax though, and the rest of Persistence is pretty middling and overly bloated. The longer track times don’t always work in the band’s favor, and the added darkness doesn’t help if the material feels flat. Too many of the cuts here are just passable. Case in point, “Keep it in the Family” sounds like 4 songs duct-taped together, and none of them work well alone or together. Who knows, maybe I’m the strange one. No, it’s the masses who are wrong.
#6. Worship Music (2011) — With all the drama surrounding the recording of this one, it’s beyond amazing we got anything worthwhile at all. Anthrax recorded one version with Bush, then another with some unknown dude from Long Island, before finally bringing Joey Belladonna back to lay down the vocals. And you can quickly tell these songs were written with Bush in mind, and Joey really worked to make them fit his voice. Despite all that, Worship Music was one helluva comeback for a band most everyone had written off as extremely fucking dead. Since I was slated to review this, I dreaded another Vol.
#5. Fistful of Metal (1984) — Ah, the mostly forgotten debut. This one is often overlooked since it doesn’t sound like the version of Anthrax most folks know, as this is basically a classic heavy metal album. That all said, this is a righteous slab o’ metal in its own right with a series of classic songs that Thrax still break out live now and then. There’s no disputing that “Deathrider” is a great song full of 80s power and one of the best the band ever penned. It’s like Motörhead meeting Exciter and Omen in battle, and only the listener survives. “Metal Thrashing Mad” went on to become a pillar of their live sets, and “Soldiers of Metal” is so 80s it hurts right in that 80s place. Neil Turbin’s rough, battle-ready vocals channel Paul Di’Anno, and the material feels mean, gritty, and street-lethal. Deep cut “Howling Furies” is one of my favorite metal tunes ever, and that line about the butcher knife is pure fucking poetry. This one deserves your love, but do YOU deserve a Fistful of Metal?
#4. State of Euphoria (1988) — This is what I consider the last release of the band’s golden age. It was the logical sequel to the surprisingly successful Among the Living, and I admired Anthrax for not trying to sell out here when they so easily could have, given their newfound fame. Euphoria has their classic sound and energy, but with a darker edge which they would continue to explore on Persistence of Time; the hooks here are still razor-sharp and plentiful. The writing is geared toward memorable moments with big choruses, and they all land, but it never feels like Anthrax is writing for greater radio play since they included a cover of Trust’s punk anthem “Antisocial” to lube the airwaves for them instead. Tracks like “Now It’s Dark” and Misery Loves Company” were plenty dark, but you could sing those catchy choruses loudly in a grocery store or at the local church. Did the lyrics get too cutesy and try-hard clever at times? Absolutely, and there are some truly cringe-worthy lines, especially on “Finale,” but that’s part of the Anthrax experience. Take it or leave it, chumbo.
#3. For All Kings (2016) — It kills a small part of my rusted, raged soul to rank this above enduring classics like Fistful and State of Euphoria, but truth must be spoken to the filthy, rotting masses. Yes, the second installment of the Joey Belladonna redemption arc is that good. I hoped for something as solid as Worship Music, and got clobbered by a vital, adventurous version of Anthrax that sounds like the 80s are back, but the band is older, wiser, and better able to expand their sound in smart ways. From how they come out swinging on “You Gotta Believe” and into “Monster at the End,” you can’t help but be impressed by just how classically Anthrax the material is. What seals the deal for me is how the album sounds like classic Thrax, but a more mature, world-weary version of the band. The 80s/90s version could never have pulled off a massive mood piece like “Blood Eagle Wings,” but now they can. They even inject wistful melancholy into cuts like “Breathing Lightning” without disrupting the album’s identity. For All Kings isn’t perfect, but it’s light-years better than anything the Big Four released since the early 90s. Look who had the last laugh!
#2. Among the Living (1987) — This is likely to be the winner in most Anthrax catalog rankings, and I certainly understand why. This was the album that truly broke the band through to mainstream consciousness with MTV running “hit” single “Indians” heavily outside of Headbangers Ball. The track listing reads like a who’s who of their best-known cuts like the title track, “Caught in a Mosh,” and “I Am the Law.” This is the sound of a band sure of their identity and writing from a place of confident inspiration. The material has a rowdy, carefree vibe that could only come from a New York upbringing, as if they’re poking you in the chest and daring you to find fault with what they were doing. My friends and I beat this album to absolute death the year it came out as we watched Anthrax’s public profile rise and escape the confines of underground metal. It seemed like the world was their oyster and that these cats would be bigger than Jesus. I still love this one and always will, but the back half is less amazing than the front, and I’ll never think of it as their best output.
#1. Spreading the Disease (1985) — This is the real magic bullet in the Thrax arsenal. Coming off the decidedly different Fistful of Metal debut, Neil Turbin was streeted, and in came Joey Belladonna with his much larger range and charisma. The sound shifted to a more thrashed out focus with a punk energy under the surface, and the writing was sharp and tight. Opener “A.I.R” grabs you around the neck and holds you in place as the band introduces you to the new sound, and there’s no denying they found the secret recipe here. Even the clunky, chunky production by Carl Canedy works somehow, giving everything a loveably rough, unfinished sound. Joey blows the doors off on eternal classics like “Madhouse,” “Aftershock,” “Armed and Dangerous,” and “Medusa,” and Thrax even dabble in moody prog on the brilliant cut “The Enemy.” Then there’s the closer “Gung Ho,” which at the time was the fastest shit anyone had ever heard. This is a flawless album that successfully marries the classic heavy metal sound of Fistful of Metal with thrash, and this is where Anthrax was and always will be at their very best. Blast “Medusa” at ear-bleeding volumes and tell me I’m wrong. Yeah, I thought so. Everything is in the right place at exactly the right time here, and it will forever go down as one of the best albums of the 80s. There is no other correct choice, folks.
#5. For All Kings (2016) — I’ve mentioned it before, but 2016 evidenced a ridiculously strong year for thrash metal titans. Megadeth and Testament put out very strong records, and Anthrax also carried the torch with For All Kings. The continuity of quality from Worship Music to For All Kings satisfies in every, and the album is laden with earworms and creative riffing bolstered by a sense of drama Anthrax never previously deployed. Outside the band’s elite material, For All Kings is the album I return to most often, and that’s largely thanks to “Breathing Lightning.” This tune unabashedly rips and remains a staple in my road trip playlists, and the Dark Tower references intensify my affection even further. Several other tracks draw me back as well, including “Monster at the End,” “Blood Eagle Wings,” and especially “All of Them Thieves.” For a band thirty-five years in,
